| Platinum | Mighty Scoops |
| Gold | Scooptopia |
| Silver | Trueman Blueberry Farms |
| Bronze | Cremerie Bennic Dairy Bar |
| Top Pick | King's Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Lost & Found Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Papamimi's Treats |
| Top Pick | Salisbury Flea Market |
| Top Pick | The Ice Cream Barn |
| Top Pick | Wacky Waffles |